Key Points in this Article
We scored 1,161 independent U.S. agency websites on distinction, and most sound like every other agency. They describe a category instead of what makes them different, and the positioning they do have is buried where prospects have to work a little too hard to find it.
- 28% of Agencies Scored WORSE than Generic
- 92% of Homepage Main Messages are Unclear or Generic
- 54% of Agencies Bury the Lede
- Size has No Bearing on Clarity of Agency Positioning
- Naming Your Ideal Client Isn’t Enough
As of November 4, 2026, we’ve scored the homepages and secondary pages of 1,161 independent, U.S. agencies with 15 to 100 employees. We rated each site across six dimensions that create distinction. A prospect visiting the site should understand:
- who the agency serves
- what problems they solve
- what they believe
- who they compete with.
We also analyzed the distinctiveness of the agency’s language and the memorability of the main message.
28% of Agencies Scored WORSE than Generic
Of those 321 agencies, 99% never clearly say what they are the alternative to, and almost two-thirds (205) score 2 or lower on all six questions. A prospect comparing these agencies sees no reason to pick them over an alternative. I’d be willing to bet (and I’m not a gambler) these agencies feel a lot of pricing pushback. Because, when you look at an agency just like the one I currently use or talked to yesterday, inevitably, the decision comes down to price.
92% of Homepage Main Messages are Unclear or Generic
I have to admit. This finding blew me away until I started manual processing, when I personally visited over 500 agencies’ websites. (More on that later.) Of 1,161 homepages, ONLY one scored a 5 on its main message. One in seven (170) had no headline at all. Instead, the hero section contained only a logo, the company name, a video, or section labels like “Our Services.”
And where a headline was found, the most common words were marketing, agency, digital, brands, creative, and growth: words that describe a category or an outcome, not an agency.
54% of Agencies Bury the Lede
More than half of agencies bury the closest thing they offer to positioning on the About, Services, or Industries page. By forcing a prospective client to click through to secondary and, in some cases, tertiary pages to find meaningful information, these agencies fail the 90-second test. Which means many agencies had a decent story. They just didn’t lead with it.
If they moved their distinction sentence from the About page to the top of the Homepage, prospects would find it within 90 seconds. And in a world where prospects continue to have less and less time, that might mean the difference between getting the call and hearing about the review after the fact.
Size has No Bearing on Clarity of Agency Positioning
A 100-person agency was just as likely to sound beige as a 15-person one. The correlation between headcount and score was 0.04, which is effectively zero. Interestingly, four of the ten top-scoring agencies have 15 to 18 employees. So small agencies are not at a disadvantage here, and that means you smaller agencies can’t hide behind the cobbler’s kids any longer.
Naming Your Ideal Client Isn’t Enough
Only 11% of the 223 agencies that named an ideal client on their homepage scored 3 or higher on our 1–5 scale. But 84% of the 105 agencies that named an ideal client AND stated the problem they solve, what they’re the alternative to, or a distinct point of view scored above 3 on our scale.
Another interesting thing I noticed in my personal review of hundreds of agency pages is that everybody’s ideal client is basically the same: the client that wants great, powerful, creative, effective work, or any combination of those.
My Anecdotal Observations
While we did rely on an AI agent using a scoring rubric that we developed to do the first scoring pass, to ensure quality, I personally verified the scores of somewhere between 300 and 500 agencies, maybe more, by visiting their websites myself. While I didn’t keep statistical notes, I can tell you that after visiting all these agencies over the span of about 7 days, a few key themes stood out to me:
Girl power rules. There are a ton of women-owned agencies, and they are all proudly trumpeting that fact, both in copy and/or by utilizing a women-owned business logo somewhere in the agency, often in the footer or sometimes even in dedicated content blocks.
PR firms are increasingly uncomfortable just being PR firms. While I was certainly able to find a number of PR agencies that were just fine calling themselves a PR agency, most PR firms made a point of noting they also offer branding and creative services. I’m not sure whether they’re trying to shift into the full-service agency realm or are in the midst of such a shift. They may not yet be ready to call themselves full service, but they are clearly trying to position themselves as more than just a public relations firm.
If you’re a creatively driven, brand-focused firm in Los Angeles, you are loud and proud. Your website is colorful, full of attitude, with lots of 300-point fonts screaming beliefs at you. You probably won’t bother to tell the prospective client much about the actual people behind the attitude, but there will be plenty of attitude. Unfortunately, as you go from one to the other, beyond the attitude, there really wasn’t much to base a selection decision on.
It’s important to agencies that you know they’re friendly, they’re fun, they’re great people to work with, they’re committed to their clients, and they’re all about creating success for those clients. They’re also dog people. The number of times I would peruse the team page showing an agency’s employees and, at some point in my scroll, come across a dog with a cute dog title was a little stunning. While I do recall seeing maybe one or two cats, the agency world, at least on their websites, is decidedly dog people.
There were other things, trends, etc., that I noticed, but I’ll keep those to myself for now. Maybe I’ll write about them in a future post, or when they become more dominant themes. If you’re interested in following along, sign up for our blog to be notified first of each new finding we release.
How The Data Was Measured
- Who: 1,161 U.S. agencies with 15 to 100 employees, pulled from Apollo and screened October 22–26, 2026.
- What: the homepage (first impression) and the pages in the main menu (read path). Blog and thought-leadership content was not part of this screen.
- How: an AI model applied fixed written criteria for each 1–5 level; averages and the overall score (homepage and menu pages blended 5:3) are formula-based. Scores can shift slightly between runs.
- Limits: A low score reflects what the website says, not the quality of an agency’s work or the agency.

